On 25 Jul 2002 at 2:49, kharin wrote:
>
> "The misplacement of semen was not possible in lesbian encounters,"
>
> You don't think that Aquinas was entertaining the same view on that issue that Queen Victoria did? I rather suspect we are speaking of an omerta on that subject rather than an exemption. The basic gist of Aquinan philosophy in this area is that non-generative sex was unnatural; that would
certainly apply to lesbianism even if no explicit comment was made on the issue. Particularly given that Eve's actions had (to Aquinas) rendered woman a flawed value whose existence was only made other than a mistake by virtue of the fact that there was no other route to perpetuate the natural
order.
>
> "then the only reason that male homosexual relations could
> be more offensive than, say, masturbation or withdrawal (onanism, after
> Onan, who spilled his seed on the ground) would have to be the
> conspiritorial/consensual nature of the act, requiring two people."
>
> Exactly; the opprobrium on that issue related to a wider 'ethics of repression' (which in turn relates to the model of relations between man and god being essentially that of feudal servitude).
>
I still consider that the ban was motivated by population/political
concerns rather than by metaphysical ones. I also note that, as has
come out recently, there has been another omerta operating, in the
matter of the willing acceptance of homosexual clergy (of both genders,
I'll wager) who for the last thousand years were officially exempted from
the directive to 'be fruitful and multiply', so that their loyalties would not
be divided between church and family.
>
> Incidentallt, I do hope this quibbling on my part has not created the impression that I am anything other than in general agreement with the principles of your original essay and generally consider it a fine piece of work.
>
Danka.
> ----
> This message was posted by kharin to the Virus 2002 board on Church of Virus BBS.
> <http://virus.lucifer.com/bbs/index.php?board=51;action=display;threadid=25764>
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Sun Sep 22 2002 - 05:06:16 MDT