No, I would not agree with that at all. Echoes are not memes.
>You tell me what hypothesis
>concerning memes you would like an experiment created for and I'll see
>if I can come up with an experiment that tests that hypothesis.
Well, I would be happy to find, in the brain, the first effector of a
behavior. The behavior would need to be simplified immensely, like an
eye-movement towards a specific area. Or I would be happy to show a
situation where a like behavior can be shown to require a meme, or not
require a meme, and the requisite brain scan or other evidence that said
behavior can happen with two different sets of electro-chemical
effectors, such that one is autonomous (or learned by habit and rote) and
one is cultural, that is, some level of conscious thought is needed- (or
simply two distinct brain activations can produce the same result.)
My initial and specific idea was to examine dream states, since I
consider dream states to be absent of memes, since there is no behavior,
but there is internal 'mapping'.
But you see, I am also in the camp of the neuro-biologists here- I do not
think the meme will be found any other way, and that what is 'found' is a
somewhat handy but diffuse and vague bunch of ramblings about ideas and
mind, all tossing out at sea in a raft without a sail.
*****************
Wade T. Smith
morbius@channel1.com | "There ain't nothin' you
wade_smith@harvard.edu | shouldn't do to a god."
******* http://www.channel1.com/users/morbius/ *******