You are demanding their existence yourself when you claim that they
were *discovered*. All we really have are a bunch of phenomena, and
then a theory which requires the existence of electrons that is used
to describe these phenomena.
I think the problem you're having is that memes are (largely if not
entirely) nonphysical objects. You've mentioned Freud in a way that
suggests you support his ideas. But 'superego' is sort of like
'meme' in the sense that it is just useful to describe phenomena.
Do you also reject Freud on the basis that nobody has proven that
id, ego, and superego exist? Are they the only way to describe
psychoanalytical observations? I don't thinks so.... in fact,
the memetics/genetics combination may do a better job, and may
even be a bit more logical at face value than Freud's theory.
(Please note my background is not in psychoanalysisat all, so
comments, constructive ones, are more than welcome for the above.)
- JPSchneider
-schneids@centuryinter.net