Does my Karma run over your Dogma? |
|
|
A) Ethics trump morals because they derive from consideration and experience, whereas morals are merely replicated. | 61.98 | (99.49%) |
B) I consider reason a virtue but see C. | 0.06 | (0.10%) |
C) Morals have survived longer term selective pressures. Ethics lie too prone to untested speculation. Virtue remains a moral issue. | 0.26 | (0.41%) |
|
decisiveness | | (61.73%) |
unvoted equity | | (36.10%) |
voted equity | | (63.90%) |
|
19 Voters: Sat, Walter Watts, MoEnzyme, Pabreetzio, Drakeo Vortex, outlawpoet, DrSebby, Kid-A, Rhysenn, simul, chippedlogic, ElvenSage, pickler, Hermit, archangelsin, goomba, teh, deusdiabolus, Fox, |
voter | voted for | comment |
Walter Watts | abstained | no comment |
MoEnzyme | A) Ethics trump morals because they derive from consideration and experience, whereas morals are merely replicated.
| no comment |
Pabreetzio | C) Morals have survived longer term selective pressures. Ethics lie too prone to untested speculation. Virtue remains a moral issue.
| Sometimes there must be a teleological suspension of the ethical. The question is porely worded. |
Drakeo Vortex | private | no comment |
outlawpoet | private | no comment |
DrSebby | B) I consider reason a virtue but see C.
| i still cannot be sure what the difference is? they are almost interchangeable in the dictionary. |
Kid-A | B) I consider reason a virtue but see C.
| no comment |
Rhysenn | private | no comment |
simul | B) I consider reason a virtue but see C.
| ethics and morals are useful. some things, like the existence of reality, and the amorality of murder, must be taken on faith |
chippedlogic | B) I consider reason a virtue but see C.
| poorly worded. reason is a virtue as are ethics, but morals are acquired. in reality all virtues are biological timebombs, saving actions to be saved or wasted. yes? |
ElvenSage | private | no comment |
Sat | private | no comment |
pickler | private | no comment |
Hermit | A) Ethics trump morals because they derive from consideration and experience, whereas morals are merely replicated.
| Morals are not a fixed mark. At some point and location every "moral" has either been a necessity or an anathema. Ethics depend on reason, a virtue. |
archangelsin | C) Morals have survived longer term selective pressures. Ethics lie too prone to untested speculation. Virtue remains a moral issue.
| no comment |
goomba | private | no comment |
teh | A) Ethics trump morals because they derive from consideration and experience, whereas morals are merely replicated.
| no comment |
deusdiabolus | A) Ethics trump morals because they derive from consideration and experience, whereas morals are merely replicated.
| no comment |
Fox | A) Ethics trump morals because they derive from consideration and experience, whereas morals are merely replicated.
| The only rational conclusion here. |