Saints: real or fictional? |
Should fictional characters be eligible for Virian illumination (sainthood)? |
| |
Yes | 0.50 | (0.58%) |
No | 86.59 | (99.42%) |
|
decisiveness | | (86.09%) |
unvoted equity | | (12.90%) |
voted equity | | (87.10%) |
|
25 Voters: Ophis, Casey, David Lucifer, the.bricoleur, Walter Watts, Sat, prometheus, Kid-A, ElvenSage, opsima, Matt Arnold, michelle, outlawpoet, DrSebby, MoEnzyme, Alex Future Bokov, DJ dAndroid, Drakeo Vortex, chippedlogic, Pabreetzio, simul, pickler, Hermit, goomba, teh, |
voter | voted for | comment |
Ophis | No
| Fictional characters can be a good source of inspiration, but sainthood should be reserved for entities who had to make choices and sacrifices for what they believed in. |
Casey | No
| no comment |
David Lucifer | No
| no comment |
the.bricoleur | No
| huh? |
Walter Watts | No
| no comment |
Sat | private | no comment |
prometheus | private | no comment |
Kid-A | No
| no comment |
ElvenSage | No
| no comment |
opsima | No
| A saint should be someone one can aspire towards. Fictional characters arise from their author's imagination, and its hard to aspire towards a figment of someone's creation. |
Matt Arnold | Yes
| There is no real person who should be sainted. Any worthy role-model is just an abstraction. |
michelle | Yes
| A saint's life is a parable, why not allow fiction? It's the illustration that counts. |
outlawpoet | Yes
| no comment |
DrSebby | No
| too easy. in fact just one 'perfect' saint could be conjured up, making the whole deal rather silly. |
MoEnzyme | No
| no comment |
Alex Future Bokov | No
| no comment |
DJ dAndroid | No
| But rather another category? Icons - or... something? |
Drakeo Vortex | private | no comment |
chippedlogic | private | no comment |
Pabreetzio | No
| no comment |
simul | No
| no comment |
pickler | No
| no comment |
Hermit | No
| Some "historical" characters are likely fictional (e.g. Jesus, King David) and some fictional characters likely had prototypes (Prometheus). Still I suggest that we select those we weyken to be real. Reality bites. |
goomba | No
| no comment |
teh | No
| no comment |
|
|