Are humans capable of being selfless? |
Do you think humans are capable of being truely selfless? |
| |
Yes | 6.97 | (10.40%) |
No | 4.77 | (7.12%) |
Undecided | 55.25 | (82.48%) |
|
decisiveness | | (48.28%) |
unvoted equity | | (6.41%) |
voted equity | | (93.59%) |
|
55 Voters: Blunderov, ElvenSage, Hermit, Ophis, rhinoceros, Kid-A, DrSebby, Matt Arnold, outlawpoet, Flux, RavenBlack, David Lucifer, goomba, prometheus, Walter Watts, Hermitess, referent, Warlock, the.bricoleur, Smucker, Cassidy McGurk, Kalkor, Sat, Kharin, Mermaid, opsima, Casey, michelle, Lukian The Wizard, MoEnzyme, simul, Aryn Ravenlocke, atra, metahuman, Rhysenn, Galt, Gunit, Nikolai, Atheist Crusader, Cydonia, LenKen, Joe Dees, nedwob, Drakeo Vortex, ZenWarrior, Heretician, Alex Future Bokov, chippedlogic, Pabreetzio, pickler, archangelsin, teh, deusdiabolus, Fox, Bohandez, |
voter | voted for | comment |
Mermaid | private | no comment |
opsima | private | no comment |
Blunderov | private | no comment |
Casey | private | no comment |
michelle | Yes
| no comment |
Flux | Yes
| Yes, genetically driven, but still good moral ideas and values can be created and carried out, as loss to the genome of the individual, but at an advantage to the culture. |
Kid-A | Yes
| yah like I was walking down the street like and this blind dude asked me where he was, so I told him, I mean I could have sent him into an oncoming vehicle or something...if that wasnt a selfless act I dunno what is..... |
Lukian The Wizard | No
| no comment |
MoEnzyme | Yes
| I think that humans generally act on some combination of selfish and selfless (memetic?) motives. Whether or not selflessness is normal or good, I would have to conclude that we have such a capacity. It's part of what makes people memetically receptive. |
simul | Yes
| Selfless in that all "returns" for service are spiritual/intangible... not physical. IE: I give my vote and comment - in return I get a sense of community and the possiblity of a rational future. |
Walter Watts | No
| You mean like when we lay jelly donuts next to anthills? |
Aryn Ravenlocke | private | no comment |
atra | No
| Read the selfish gene heh |
metahuman | Yes
| no comment |
Rhysenn | No
| no comment |
Galt | No
| no comment |
Gunit | Yes
| no comment |
Nikolai | private | no comment |
Atheist Crusader | private | no comment |
LenKen | Yes
| People who help close kin sometimes do so to the detriment of their selves (though not their genes), and countless people throw their lives away for the benefit of memes. Is that truly selfless? You decide. |
Matt Arnold | Undecided
| Depends on what this means! Of course people are able to be altruistic or authoritarian drones. But this serves their drives and needs, which is their self. |
Joe Dees | No
| no comment |
nedwob | Yes
| no comment |
Drakeo Vortex | private | no comment |
ZenWarrior | Yes
| It takes knowing of only one exception of selfishness to require an answer of "yes." Of at least one, I am aware. |
Heretician | private | no comment |
Alex Future Bokov | No
| no comment |
chippedlogic | Yes
| no comment |
Pabreetzio | Yes
| That is the idea this church is based upon, isnt it? Thats what memes do to us- make us selfless |
pickler | Yes
| most definitely! |
archangelsin | Yes
| no comment |
teh | Yes
| no comment |
deusdiabolus | Yes
| ...but it requires a lot of effort and dedication. |
Fox | No
| As far as I can determine there is no such thing as a selfless act without a selfish motive. |
Bohandez | No
| no comment |
|
|